Menu
Log in
How Much Sugar?

Boost metabolism vs eat when hungry

  • 29 Mar 2011 5:14 PM
    Message # 557132
    Deleted user
    I'm confused!  I'm going well with the sugar-free, having been on this lifestyle since 1 March.  My appetite is starting to be recognisable to me now - first time in a long time!  So my confusion lies around what we've always been told - to eat small and often and always to eat breakfast to boost your metabolism.  However I'm finding I'm just not usually hungry in the morning and so haven't been eating, which flies in the face of the advice I've always been given.

    Any thoughts?

    Cheers
    Michelle
  • 29 Mar 2011 10:52 PM
    Reply # 557361 on 557132
    Deleted user
    Michelle Austin wrote: I'm confused!  I'm going well with the sugar-free, having been on this lifestyle since 1 March.  My appetite is starting to be recognisable to me now - first time in a long time!  So my confusion lies around what we've always been told - to eat small and often and always to eat breakfast to boost your metabolism.  However I'm finding I'm just not usually hungry in the morning and so haven't been eating, which flies in the face of the advice I've always been given.

    Any thoughts?

    Cheers
    Michelle

    Hello Michelle
    many congrats on starting the sugar free way and how great that your appetite is starting to come under control now.
    Well, our new advice is to eat when hungry and stop when we are full. This means that if your body doesn't want breakfast, don't give it any until it demands some! I don't think it's going to affect your metabolism one way or the other. I expect you're finding that you don't need to eat all those little and often meals now. And as your body is now able to metabolize away happily till it needs some more food and you are now aware of this...................don't rock the boat. It will all sort itself out now that you are no longer poisoning it with fructose.

    cheers Freda
    Last modified: 29 Mar 2011 10:52 PM | Deleted user
  • 30 Mar 2011 4:23 AM
    Reply # 557482 on 557132
    Deleted user
    I'd try to eat a little less in the evenings and see if you are hungrier in the morning as an experiment.

    Getting hungry to a comfortable level is important ...once or twice a day at the least. 

    I often have breakfast and I'm not hungry, I just want to start the day, and not get hungry at an inconvenient time at work. But it's a small breakfast so I hit lunch hungry, and then the same for the evening meal. I can certainly tolerate a bit of hunger better now off sugar. Makes all the difference to losing weight.  Good luck with some experimentation!
  • 30 Mar 2011 6:47 AM
    Reply # 557516 on 557361
    Deleted user
    Freda Surgenor wrote:
    Michelle Austin wrote: I'm confused!  I'm going well with the sugar-free, having been on this lifestyle since 1 March.  My appetite is starting to be recognisable to me now - first time in a long time!  So my confusion lies around what we've always been told - to eat small and often and always to eat breakfast to boost your metabolism.  However I'm finding I'm just not usually hungry in the morning and so haven't been eating, which flies in the face of the advice I've always been given.

    Any thoughts?

    Cheers
    Michelle

    Hello Michelle
    many congrats on starting the sugar free way and how great that your appetite is starting to come under control now.
    Well, our new advice is to eat when hungry and stop when we are full. This means that if your body doesn't want breakfast, don't give it any until it demands some! I don't think it's going to affect your metabolism one way or the other. I expect you're finding that you don't need to eat all those little and often meals now. And as your body is now able to metabolize away happily till it needs some more food and you are now aware of this...................don't rock the boat. It will all sort itself out now that you are no longer poisoning it with fructose.

    cheers Freda

    Thanks Freda - it's hard letting go of old beliefs and habits sometimes.
  • 30 Mar 2011 6:50 AM
    Reply # 557517 on 557482
    Deleted user
    Julie McNaught wrote: I'd try to eat a little less in the evenings and see if you are hungrier in the morning as an experiment.

    Getting hungry to a comfortable level is important ...once or twice a day at the least. 

    I often have breakfast and I'm not hungry, I just want to start the day, and not get hungry at an inconvenient time at work. But it's a small breakfast so I hit lunch hungry, and then the same for the evening meal. I can certainly tolerate a bit of hunger better now off sugar. Makes all the difference to losing weight.  Good luck with some experimentation!

    Heh heh, I actually ate a smaller dinner last night Julie - then was awakened at 2:30am by my 4 year old, and couldn't get back to sleep because I was hungry!  I like the idea of a smaller dinner, and I like the idea of a small breakfast (which is all I've been having) setting me up until lunch time.  Experimenting is kind of cool now that I'm not hungry and dissatisfied all the time :-)

    Thanks for your thoughts,
    Michelle
  • 16 Apr 2011 7:36 AM
    Reply # 571837 on 557132
    Deleted user

    Most of my life, up until my late 20's anyway, I just ate when hungry. When I ate, it wasn't heaps, but it was good simple food and plenty enough for me. My family pretty much gave me hell over this, with the "you should eat 3 meals a day" stuff. In the 80's and 90's everyone was also worried about anorexia and bulemia. I was neither of these (my sister was bulemic though). I was always very physically active, a tom-boy type, "stocky" (muscular) 5'3" female around 55kg. 

    I tried to respond with "you don't try and fill up your car when it's full of fuel, do you?" but still I copped the grief. So eventually, I succumbed, and did the 3 meals a day thing from about the age of 30. It did take a few years, but now I'm 43 years old and weigh 76kg, and boy I wish I had listened to my own body instead of what everyone around me pressured me with. I have been trying all the usual prescribed ways to get back to where I was for years, and nothing has worked.

    David's book was music to my ears. What he's described is how I always used to eat. So familial pressure be damned, I'm going back to eating how I used to, how it suits me and my body, and as it turns out, I was always in line with the fructose/sugar free thing. Having read "sweet poison", I understand now the physics of why what I always did worked, and that's good enough for me.

    Stick with it people, whether you lose weight or not. This is the way to eat, live, and enjoy your life!

Powered by Wild Apricot Membership Software