Menu
Log in
How Much Sugar?

children and dextrose

  • 18 Oct 2011 6:23 PM
    Message # 726353
    Deleted user
    I was just wondering if dextrose/rice syrup creates the same behavioural changes in children as normal sugar does?

  • 19 Oct 2011 12:36 AM
    Reply # 726553 on 726353
    Deleted user

    I have started cutting down all sugar that my daughter takes (she will be 5 next month), as she is learning about healthy foods, so I am now getting more strict on what she eats and there is no more sugar.  She is definitely calmer and loves all the dextrose baking.  I don't think they go as "crazy" when they eat dextrose, they just get big bursts of energy without going crazy like they are high or something.

  • 19 Oct 2011 7:15 AM
    Reply # 726714 on 726353
    Deleted user
    Is there any evidence that sugar makes kids go 'crazy'?  The infamous red cordial effect is most probably the food colouring in the cordial, not the sugar.  Sue Dengate of the Food Additives Network (http://fedup.com.au/) argues that what parents may think is a sugar high is more likely to be the artificial colours, flavours and preservatives that are commonly found in sugary foods, especially foods marketed at children.  And some colours are worse than others (yellow and orange, for instance).
  • 19 Oct 2011 7:12 PM
    Reply # 727176 on 726353
    Deleted user

    All I know is if I give my kids any type of sugar, even from something I bake myself they go crazy.  As what David says in his books about the sugar high and low.  I think that before eating sugar, kids are at a sugar low, when they eat the sugar they get that sugar high, so they have heaps of energy.  We all know some of the stuff that kids eat these days are loaded with sugar.  I don't think the effects on adults are the same as kids.  Take my daughter for example, she is quite tiny, only 16kgs and turning 5 next year.  If she ate say a piece of cake, like a packet mix one, Green's brand moist vanilla has a whopping 24g of sugar for just 1/12 of a slice which is only 65g.  I think this amount of sugar in 1 hit for 1 kid is too much for their body to handle and too much energy at once.  If I ate the same piece, I'm currently 76.9kgs, it wouldn't have the same effect because my body is well slightly bigger then 16kgs.  That's my way of thinking anyway.  I've been giving my daughter dextrose and although she gets that burst of energy it's not too much for her body to handle and she doesn't go as crazy.

Powered by Wild Apricot Membership Software