Menu
Log in
How Much Sugar?

Carbs = fat etc

  • 21 Mar 2012 8:58 PM
    Message # 865423
    Deleted user

    Hi, Couple of years back when talking to my dietitian about carbs she told me that whatever the body doesn't use for fuel will be converted into fat. So when trying to drop your kgs you must watch your portion* size in carbs.  

    Q1 - My first question is apart from watching your sugar (fructose) intake there is more to it than just sugar?

    Q2 - My second question or rather more a comment: When cutting out sugar (fructose) mainly via the processed foods you are also cutting down on the other very nasty trans fats which are found in most processed foods. So my point is that it is not just taking out the sugar which will contritute to your weight loss.

    * Dietitian showed me with a plastic model the normal portion sizes (rice pasta etc).  I was shocked & confessed that I would eat 3 times that size in a meal. 

    PS I have been doing the sugar free for 1.5 week & have dropped 1kg.  I have found it no problem as I have never been into soft drinks, sugar in coffee/tea but processed foods & biscuits savoury treats is probably more my problem & portion size in the carb department!  Feeling good so far.   

     

  • 21 Mar 2012 9:41 PM
    Reply # 865443 on 865423
    Deleted user
    Kaye, don't over think it. If going fructose free leads to other changes which further improves your health is that a problem?

    Personally reducing sugar led me to reducing carbs generally and then to Primal style eating. I don't care how or why, that's what happened and I am so glad it did.
  • 22 Mar 2012 1:38 AM
    Reply # 865572 on 865423
    Anonymous
    Your dietitian, like most health professionals, is probably unaware of the effect fructose has on your appetite-control system, the four hormones in your stomach which tell you when you're hungry and when you've had enough - of carbs, fats, anything. 

    So when you stop ingesting fructose your appetite-control system quickly reverts to normal, so there won't be any excess carbs, since you won't take in more than your body needs at that time.

    The carbs which will be converted to fat are the fructose component of your food, since any amount over the 10g per day that you need,goes directly to the liver where it is converted to fat.
  • 22 Mar 2012 3:39 AM
    Reply # 865654 on 865423
    Deleted user
    But we don't actually NEED any fructose at all, the cells in our body make what they need from the glucose.
    this article explains: http://fructosefree.com/ See the second paragraph.
    cheers
    Freda
    Last modified: 22 Mar 2012 3:40 AM | Deleted user
  • 22 Mar 2012 8:03 PM
    Reply # 866322 on 865423
    Deleted user
    Kaye McIntosh wrote:

    Hi, Couple of years back when talking to my dietitian about carbs she told me that whatever the body doesn't use for fuel will be converted into fat. So when trying to drop your kgs you must watch your portion* size in carbs.  

    Q1 - My first question is apart from watching your sugar (fructose) intake there is more to it than just sugar?

    Q2 - My second question or rather more a comment: When cutting out sugar (fructose) mainly via the processed foods you are also cutting down on the other very nasty trans fats which are found in most processed foods. So my point is that it is not just taking out the sugar which will contritute to your weight loss.

    * Dietitian showed me with a plastic model the normal portion sizes (rice pasta etc).  I was shocked & confessed that I would eat 3 times that size in a meal. 

    PS I have been doing the sugar free for 1.5 week & have dropped 1kg.  I have found it no problem as I have never been into soft drinks, sugar in coffee/tea but processed foods & biscuits savoury treats is probably more my problem & portion size in the carb department!  Feeling good so far.   

     


    The problem is everyone is different and what works for me may not necessiarly work for someone else. I find that I just cannot eat too many carbs myself, they don't really fill me up nor keep me full long enough.  I don't eat bread, although I do have small amounts of carbs every day but I do limit them and I fill up on protein and fats first (if we are having pasta for dinner I will have a salad with it or more meat like bolognaise or meatballs and serve myself less pasta).  My husband on the other hand, he can eat all the carbs he likes and does have a sandwich every day for lunch however they don't react the same way with me as it does to him.  It really is all about portion and the amount we eat.  We really don't need much to function, and the trick is to fill up on protein and fats, they will keep you fuller for longer.  Before I started my sugar free journey I used to do low fat calorie counting.  It did work, I did loose weight, I always made sure I served my small portion, however I felt like I was starving all the time because the sugar destroyed my appetite control and I found that I kept snacking in between and eventually kept putting weight back on.  Now I'm eating the same amount as before, and I even tried for fun counting my calories the other day, I'm getting less calories, my portions are the same however all the protein is keeping me fuller so I'm not snacking.
  • 22 Mar 2012 9:07 PM
    Reply # 866370 on 865423
    Deleted user

    Thanks for all your info. I must confess I have not had what I call snack attack! Not hungry just craving for something (that must be the fructose).

    There must be some use for fructose? For those who can't put on weight or need to increase their appetite for various reasons?

     

     

  • 22 Mar 2012 10:05 PM
    Reply # 866432 on 865423
    Deleted user
    Unfortunately it's just plain unhealthy apart from making us want to eat more...

  • 23 Mar 2012 2:45 AM
    Reply # 866567 on 865423
    Deleted user
    Actually, fructose (Autumn fruit) used to be used by ancient man to fatten himself and his animals to get through the freezing Northern winters!!!
    I don't know about the tropics.........maybe people there used it for something else. Anyway, fruit used to be far smaller than the giant stuff we see in the shops these days.
    cheers
    Freda
  • 23 Mar 2012 4:44 AM
    Reply # 866591 on 865423
    Deleted user
    Smaller, and far less sweet too.
Powered by Wild Apricot Membership Software